Writing Off The Worlda personal blog


Scars are Souvenirs

An essay on being the man in arena; trying and not winning. Is it worth it?

15 min read

I’ve been traveling lately and as a result my writing output has suffered. I find it difficult to carve out 3-4 hours of time to work and get into a flow when I am traveling. My writing style requires this. I find that I can’t write for only 15 minutes and then come back hours or days later and continue on with a thought.

Recent experiences while traveling caused some thoughts to generate and I’ve been ruminating with them for some time. My apologies up front for the length of this post. You’ve been warned. :)

The man in the arena

One of my travels was to support a family member’s attempt to run a marathon while they carry with them a life threatening health condition. While training may have gone as expected, on the day of the race it was not to be. After 20 grueling miles, the body was tired. When the athlete walked to the next mile marker where a crowd of about 20 friends and family had gathered to cheer, they found hugs, tears and words of affirmation instead. While it was the opposite of the support that we intended to give it was, in some ways, more powerful of a statement of our feelings towards this person.

I was almost immediately reminded of Theodore Roosevelt’s speech entitled “Citizenship in a Republic” that he delivered at the Sorbonne in Paris on April 23, 1910. It is better known as “The man in the Arena” speech for its words about a quarter of the way through that resonate with so many.

It is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles, or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood; who strives valiantly; who errs, who comes short again and again, because there is no effort without error and shortcoming; but who does actually strive to do the deeds; who knows the great enthusiasms, the great devotions; who spends himself in a worthy cause; who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who neither know victory nor defeat.

Struggling isn’t appreciated

Overcoming adversity is a prized feature in much of our art world. Whether the written word, film, or song, the world is awash in tales about struggle or people being wronged and the tenacity of the human spirit. Just this summer we’ve had the recreation on the movie screen of one of the oldest tales of adversity - The Odyssey. This narrative is attributed to Homer and originated as an epic poem from the 8th century BC.

While adversity surrounds us in art, many people choose not to be aware of its presence. Instead they scroll endless screens watching people who have ‘made it’ live lives which are fantasies. They dream away their lives in the feeds of social media choosing aspiration as an escape from their own disappointments or as a goal to drive them to achieve what others have. Either way, these feeds don’t portray life as it truly is and as we know, comparison is the thief of joy. Because of this endless comparison to these misrepresented lives, many people find themselves stuck in an endless loop of unhappiness.

Is life being difficult…normal?

I think many of us expect life to be pretty boring most of the time or, at least, not challenging. We think in terms of: if I can just get this project done, if the kids can just move on to a steady job, or once I retire, then things will lighten up. We think at some point in the future that life will settle down and become easy.

The general belief for many people is that life should be easier than it seems. We should live in a better apartment or house. We should have nicer clothes. We should have a better car or job. And, our spouse or the family we grew up in should understand us and treat us better.

After all, who likes to struggle?

But the reality is that life is a series of problems and challenges; that it never becomes easy. Rather, it’s up to us to reframe how we view our daily life and the issues that we face.

Does struggling need to lead to something better?

People are captivated by stories of adversity and struggle especially when there is an identifiable reason for the struggle or a happy ending. I personally know many people who refuse to read a book or watch a movie if they know that the protagonist doesn’t win or come out better in the end. They are willing to put in the time, but only if they are rewarded in the end with a more positive outcome.

In a 2020 study in The Journal of Neuroscience, Martin Vestergaard and coauthor Wolfram Schultz demonstrate that people prefer experiences with happy endings to experiences that became slightly less enjoyable towards the end.

This is also the foundation for the Peak End Rule that Daniel Kahneman described in his book, Thinking, Fast and Slow. This rule states that people evaluate their overall experience with an event based on how it ends and their final memories of it. If it ends on a negative note (such as experiencing pain) then they will recall the entire experience in a negative view.

What if we reframed how we looked at difficulties that we face. There doesn’t need to be a rewarding outcome after we struggle with something for that struggle to have a purpose in our life.

We grow during our difficult times

The fact is that we grow, both physically and emotionally, only when we are under stress. And this has been know for some time. The book of Mark in the Christian bible highlighted the challenges early Christians faced and it was through these experiences that they learned what it was that they needed to build their faith.

Similar lessons were shared in the early Stoic writings by Marcus Aurelius and Epictetus and these became the foundations of Stoic beliefs.

A popular phrase these days pertaining to struggle that has been attributed to Aurelius is “The obstacle is the way”. This phrase is only partially accurate since this is a simplification of a translated passage. The translated phrase by Gregory Hays is:

“The impediment to action advances action. What stands in the way becomes the way.”

Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 5.20, translated by Gregory Hays

This phrase is closely related to the Stoic reserve clause. The reserve clause essentially means that a person can plan to seriously accomplish something without treating the outcome as guaranteed, or preordained. You reserve yourself from determining what the outcome of your effort will be, for it is unknown.

For example, you may want a job and so you intensely prepare for the interview. There is no guarantee that the outcome will be that you will land the job. Your purpose is to demonstrate your experience and qualifications for the job. As you fulfill this purpose, there may be unseen obstacles that arise that will prevent you from obtaining the job.

To me, this is the beauty of the Stoic philosophy. An unexpected, or external to you, obstacle can block an action. That does not determine what kind of person you are, or the person you will become. Your actions in response to the obstacle will identify the person that you are, or have become.

When conditions occur that cause you to not achieve a desired outcome, you do not have to pretend that you shouldn’t have tried in the first place because nothing mattered. You simply must adapt to the conditions, or the obstacle that you were presented with, while preserving the quality of your purpose.

Additional Stoic thoughts

A metaphor to humans growing as they encounter challenges is the concept that metal becomes stronger once it has experienced fire (intense heat, or stress).

Stoic philosopher Epictetus follows a similar line of thinking when he wrote that, “It is difficulties that show what men are.” Epictetus also used athletics as a means to teach this lesson, comparing challenges to the opponents faced by an athlete. Without difficult opponents, an athlete would never discover or develop their strength. Challenges reveal a person’s true character in addition to helping the individual build their strength and muscle (character) along the way.

Along the same line as Aurelius, Epictetus goes on to identify that it is not the fact that we face challenges that is difficult, it is the thoughts we then create about the difficulties that we faced. He said, “It is not things themselves that disturb people, but their judgments about these things.” Instead of lamenting over the cards you were dealt, “You should, then, accept the material you are given and set to work on it.”

Scars

Along the way when we encounter our life’s difficulties, some can leave a mark on us, a physical or emotional scar. Whether we got hurt by a loved one in a relationship, we lived through a dramatic health crisis, or possibly a parent walked away from their responsibility to us, we were left less perfect than we were before.

We now hurt. We now have pain. We now have a scar to carry with us for the rest of our days.

Do we embrace or hide the scars we receive?

I believe that the fabric of our life is made up of all of our experiences - the good experiences we have and the memorable days when we felt love or a part of a team, as well as the scars that we pick up along the way. I try not to assign more importance to one or the other experiences - they all matter.

A recurring discussion around fire pits in my family is whether or not a person should embrace their scars and talk about them or whether traumatic moments should be woven into your fabric, but they should be rarely shown and described to others.

Among the reasons to hide our scars is that we become repetitious bringing up the story of that experience more than once and others tire of it. It’s fine to share what happened but don’t rely on it like a crutch, I guess.

Something tells me that our difficulties demonstrate our humanity and, at a very human level, we want to share these experiences to some varying (by person) degree. Popular music seems to share this sentiment. In the 1995 hit Name by the Goo Goo Dolls, John Rzeznik shares:

Scars are souvenirs you never lose; The past is never far

I love the idea that scars are a reminder of your past, in both good and bad ways. Reminders can be a source of motivation and, I recognize, they can also be a source of torment if we haven’t yet dealt with and processed whatever harm was done to us.

Rob Thomas, in the song Bright Lights from the band Matchbox Twenty, agrees describing his situation after his love leaves him to try and find her fame in the city:

I got a hole in me now; I got a scar I can talk about

Scars become part of our fabric. They signifiy who we are; flawed or damaged human beings.

What does research show?

Just because our tough experiences have integrated themselves into the fabric of our lives, does this automatically mean that we should experience them everyday? Should we include them when we are describing our life experiences to others? Looking to discuss this beyond personal feelings and anecdotal experiences, let’s take a look at some research.

Writing about trauma has longer term benefits

A controlled study conducted by James Pennebaker in 1986 examined if writing about traumatic events could influence measures of health, negative moods and physiological arousal. The findings are a little surprising, yet completely logical. Writing about the facts and the resulting emotions surrounding traumatic events was associated with higher blood pressure and negative moods in the short term, but resulted in fewer health visits in the 6 months after the experiment.

Benefits of expression appear to be wide spread

A paper written by Pennebaker in 1997 expanded on his initial findings. Additional research between 1989 and 1997 found that writing and talking about emotional topics was associated with improved immune function and antibody response. In addition, self reporting substantiated the suggestion that writing about emotional topics improved well being indicators and moods long term, even though the actual process was stressful and painful.

Mood and well being improvements are not clear cut as numerous studies failed to document the same outcomes across all people.

Some items that I found interesting about the research in this time period were:

  • The writing experiment did not include feedback to the participant.
    • The participants simply wrote about their experience and thoughts. That was enough to identify measurable changes and improvements.
  • Outcomes were similar for senior professionals with advanced degrees, college students, and maximum security prisoners with sixth grade educations.
    • Emotional maturation didn’t seem to be a factor in the ability for this effort to have positive effects on a person.
  • The value of writing versus talking about traumatic events was comparable.
    • People are able to use the manner of expression that they are most comfortable with in order to participate in this activity.
  • It was noted that the people who benefited the most from writing about their experience had a noticeable improvement in the quality of their narrative as they wrote more.
    • It seemed that if they were able to form their narrative into a more cohesive form that they were actually processing their trauma in a more effective manner.

Expressive types benefit, but others see opposite effects

In 2014, a paper was released that identified a person’s previous expressiveness was a significant indicator as to whether writing about traumatic events would provide longer term benefits. It appears that a person’s natural behavior might also be their natural elected coping approach. Those who were not naturally expressive might see the opposite effects, with anxiety indicators significantly increasing.

Recent studies and papers written as recently as 2023, appear to buttress the concept that a participant’s motivation may be a key indication of if they are likely to benefit from such a writing exercise.

Final thoughts

It’s interesting to see the progression of the research over the last nearly 40 years. The initial insight was that sharing intimate thoughts about traumatic events might be helpful. Now, the most recent research suggests that it is helpful to those individuals who are predisposed to express themselves through writing or those who are particularly motivated to use this technique.

I guess it shouldn’t surprise us to find that not everyone responds the same way. Some find expression cathartic; some find processing initially overwhelming without adequate support while others find it overwhelming no matter what. We are complicated beings and no one script seems to work for everyone.

With my innate inclination to write it stands to reason that my bias would be towards sharing ones traumatic experiences as the most natural behavior. I should have reasoned that the most obvious answer would be that…it depends. This topic is more complicated than a simple binary answer is capable of adequately addressing.

I think that Rzeznik has it right when he says, “Scars are souvenirs you never lose; The past is never far”. They are reminders of our past and sometimes, some of us would rather not be reminded of that past nor share it. And that’s okay.

For those individuals, I propose that they remind themselves of the beauty of the Stoic philosophy mentioned above. When external things, or things outside of your control, happen to you they do not define the person that you were or who you are going forward. It is your response and adaptations to those obstacles that will create the definition for the person you will beome.

Previous Reading:

Vestergaard, MD., Schultz, W. (November 11, 2020). Retrospective Valuation of Experienced Outcome Encoded in Distinct Reward Representations in the Anterior Insula and Amygdala. Journal of Neuroscience, 40 (46) 8938-8950; DOI: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.2130-19.2020

Pennebaker, JW., Klihr Beall, S. (August 1986). Confronting a Traumatic Event: Toward an Understanding of Inhibition and Disease, Journal of Abnormal Psychology Volume 95, Issue 3, pages 274-281.

Pennebaker, JW.. (May, 1997). Writing about Emotional Experiences as a Therapeutic Process, Psychological Science, Vol. 8, No. 3, pp. 162-166.

Niles, A. N., Haltom, K. E. B., Mulvenna, C. M., Lieberman, M. D., & Stanton, A. L. (2014). Randomized controlled trial of expressive writing for psychological and physical health: the moderating role of emotional expressivity. Anxiety, Stress, & Coping, 27(1), 1–17. https://doi.org/10.1080/10615806.2013.802308

Rude SS, Lantrip C, Aguirre VA and Schraegle WA. (2023). Chasing elusive expressive writing effects: emotion-acceptance instructions and writer engagement improve outcomes. Frontiers in Psychology, Volume 14 - 2023. https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1192595

Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, fast and slow. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.